Whoa, I feel like our taste buds are so opposite! I'm not into the extremes!
The yelp reviews at Oscars are really positive. I wouldn't mind giving them another try as long as it's not that soup! I wonder if it was the same salty level as what you usually like or a slipup because of the mass production. I'll take your recommendation of surf n turf for next time though (or you should post about it soon!)